The pitch promise nobody keeps.

In May the ANA and the 4As published ten principles for fixing the agency pitch. They cover timelines, RFIs, spec work, feedback, compensation, and IP ownership. Ten rules from the two bodies with the most authority over how this industry sells itself.

Not one of them requires that the people in the pitch are the people on the account.

Principle one gets closest. Under transparency, agencies "should be expected to" bring a balance of leadership and "advise who from the pitch team introduced will be working on the business." Should. The complaint clients repeat more than any other got written up as a good manner.

The sequence everyone recognises

Four senior people present. A strategy director with fifteen years in your category. A creative lead whose reel you already liked. A managing partner who says the words "we'll be close to this one."

You sign in March. By June the strategy director sits in someone else's pitch. The creative lead joins a monthly call. Your Slack channel holds one account executive, eighteen months into their career, forwarding your feedback to a freelancer you have never met.

Nobody lied. Everyone in that room meant it. Then the next pitch arrived, and closeness turned out to be the cheapest thing to cut.

The numbers

Basis surveyed more than 200 agency professionals for its 2026 agency report. 87.3% said the traditional agency model is broken or will be inside five years. 54% said client relationships have grown more strained. 65.3% watched a client move work in-house in the past twelve months.

The pitch that starts all this costs the client an average of $408,500, by the ANA and 4As' own Cost of the Pitch study. Defending an account runs the incumbent $406,092. A three-agency review passes a million dollars before anyone ships a single asset.

Then the work goes to someone two levels junior.

The one they did go after

In June, Publicis released a film called The Wrong Promises, a mock news report on how agencies buy pitches. A five million dollar bonus if the client adopts the agency's AI platform. Payment deferred until a gold Lion lands. Shopping trips to Milan. Guaranteed awards. Arthur Sadoun called it a race to the bottom and asked the industry to stop.

He was talking about the technology promise. The staffing promise went unmentioned. A holding company CEO attacked his own industry's pitch behaviour on camera, got closer than anyone else this year, and still walked past the thing clients complain about most.

The defence, and where it runs out

Agencies have an answer, and part of it holds. Procurement squeezed fees for a decade. A senior day rate against a compressed retainer does not work arithmetically. No agency can park senior capacity on an account it has not won.

All fair. All of it argues for saying so in the room.

"Our strategy director builds the framework in month one, then hands to an account manager with her reviewing monthly" is a sentence any client can price. Almost nobody says it out loud. The industry sells month one and invoices for month nine.

The second defence is that juniors need to learn, and this is how they always learned. That one held until the industry cut the people who did the teaching. Headcount at UK creative agencies fell 14.3% in the last IPA census, and 24% of British agencies expect to cut more staff this year because of AI. You cannot claim juniors are being mentored while removing the mentors.

Juniors are not the problem. Under-briefed juniors with nobody senior above them are.

What we do about it

I built Vibe Shift Studio so this question has a boring answer.

I am on the call. I write the strategy. I shoot, cut, and post the work. I run the paid. Nothing gets handed off, because there is nobody to hand it to.

That works as a constraint as much as a promise. I take a limited number of launches at a time. I publish floors instead of quoting ranges: Focused from £800, Core from £1,800, Full from £3,400, momentum retainer from £1,200 a month. Scope comes from a call, and the call is with me.

If you are reviewing agencies right now, ask one question. Name the person who will be in our Slack channel in month six, and write the name into the contract. What happens next in the room tells you what you are actually buying.

Book a call →